Hoka Mach 4 vs 5 – What is Better for Me?

My friend screams, looking at his blood blisters on the forefoot after a long daily training. He ran roughly 10 miles with me wearing Mach 4. So, I told him to change the pair. But he loves Hokas and doesn’t want to switch to other brands. I stated, “why don’t you try Mach 5? It has a wide forefoot.” However, they have common features and dissimilarities as well.

So, what is the difference between Hoka Mach 4 vs Hoka Mach 5? Mach 5 weighs 7.6 oz. while Mach 4 weighs 8.2 oz. Also, Mach 5 has better cushioning than Mach 4, yet they have the same comfort level. In other ways, Mach 5 is wider in the forefoot, preventing blisters and hot spots. 

I shared the key differences in this article side-by-side. Read them and grab the perfect one that meets your needs.

Hoka Mach 4 vs Hoka Mach 5 – Comparison Chart

I compared Mach 4 and 5 in the chart below based on their weight, heel drop, cushioning, and other specifications.

Parameter	Hoka Mach 4	Hoka Mach 5
Weight	8.2 oz.	7.6 oz.
Upper	Engineered Mesh	Engineered Mesh
Service Life	400 miles	350 miles
Cushioning	Moderate	High
Heel Drop	5 mm	10 mm
Athletic Style	Speedwork, Daily Training, Running	Speedwork, Daily Training, Running
Sizing	Men: 7-13Women: 5.5-11	Men: 7-13Women: 5.5-11
Outsole	Durable Rubber	Durable and Rigid Rubber
Midsole	PROFLY	PROFLY+
Stability	Neutral	Neutral

Feature Comparison Between Hoka Mach 4 and 5

The Hoka Mach series is popular among runners for its cushioned feel. Here, I shared the comparison in more detail so you can buy the better version.

Construction

High-quality materials are used in Mach 4 and 5. Wearers praised upper, midsole, and outsole construction. 

Mach 4 has a mesh upper to keep your feet cool. Also, the anatomical Achilles tab offers extra support in every stride. PROFLY foam in the midsole feels soft while returning less energy. Moreover, the bottom layer is designed with EVA for a lightweight feel.

Mach 5 feels comfier than its ancestor for PROFLY+ midsole. The pair is better for slower-paced runs as it returns energy efficiently. Simultaneously, the midsole compresses as required so that you will feel plushy. Outsole durability is also appreciated due to the upgraded rubber sole.

Service Life

Since both footwear are designed with quality materials, they offer excellent service life. The upper provides long-term service no matter how many miles you run. However, there are a few concerns.

The Mach 4 midsole withstands wear and tear more effectively in high-impact areas than the Mach 5. On the other hand, the Mach 5 PROFLY+ midsole provides a soft feeling for several days. A runner ran with the Mach 5 around 650 miles. Moreover, the EVA layer foam outsole of Mach 4 has low durability, while Mach 5 has a rigid outsole. 

Cushioning

Mach 4 features a gel-like cushion yet provides a bouncy feel. You can run easily with it, and it won’t sink in or get stuck while standing. Your feet will remain closer to the ground for the low-profile cushioned bed. 

Undoubtedly, PROFLY+ makes the Mach 5 more responsive and soft. Moreover, the foam doesn’t feel heavy. Instead, it feels nimble. Wearers enjoyed both easy and speedy paces as the footbed offers a comfortable run. 

Stability

High five to the bit lower stack (forefoot= 25.7 mm and heel= 30.6 mm) makes Mach 4 more stable than other Hokas. This footwear will support you if you need to go down steep hills, snowy mountains or run through a wide range of terrains. 

According to several users, the Mach 5 is not a stability shoe. Nevertheless, the footwear offers decent stability to help out. It has a solid base, which is great considering the amount of cushioning. Also, 37 mm of foam in the heel provides better stability than shoes with 31 mm.

Fit

Looking for a pair that fits like a glove?

Mach 4 will be the best choice. The pair is true to size. You can order them by comparing the size with your regular running shoes. After pulling the laces, your feet will be locked down perfectly. More importantly, Mach 4 doesn’t restrict your natural foot movement.

Alternatively, Mach 5 also fits true to size. Though you may initially feel snug around the arch, the pair feels comfy over time. Moreover, the wider toe box lets you feel no cramps. At the same time, thick tongues prevent hotspots. 

Performance Comparison Between Hoka Mach 4 and 5

So, how do they perform while standing, walking, and running? Let’s find out. 

Standing for All-day

Hoka Machs are performance shoes. Although they have cushioned midsoles, providing comfort for long periods, there are better choices for some-day wear. Both versions have narrow midfoot and firm heel counters, minimizing all-day support. 

Walking

Hoka shoes promise comfortable and smooth walking strides. Mach 4 and 5 don’t compromise comfort during waking.

They have a cushioned midsole and rocker sole shape to support longer walks. Also, mesh uppers prevent sweat formation by reducing the heat inside the shoes. Though Mach 5 feels a bit softer for the PROFLY+ foam.

Running

Then again, the PROFLY+ foam offers excellent energy return. Thus, you will enjoy effortless strikes when running. Runners who prefer snappy turnover during faster races and training would prefer Mach 5 over Mach 4. Yet, both pairs are good for recovery runs.

Hoka Mach 4 vs Hoka Mach 5 – What Should You Buy?

After reading the above comprehensive differences, it is evident that Mach 5 is a better option. Still, Mach 4 will be a good choice for good reasons.

Mach 4 is best for,

• People having tighter budgets and looking for shoes that promote fast-paced runs

Mach 5 is best for,

• Softer runs, versatile training providing responsive cushioning with lightweight construction